Homes for Sale in Remsenburg, New York

35. 53 Cedar Lane

1. 53 Cedar Lane

2. 53 Cedar Lane

1 of 35

Remsenburg, NY 11960

4 Bd5 Ba

Single Family Home

$4,150,000

5,645 SF

Reduced:5/21/2025$4,350,000(6.45%)

date	Price	variance	type
5/21/2025	$4,350,000	-6.45%	Reduced
3/27/2025	$4,650,000	+12.05%	increased
3/26/2025	$4,150,000	--	Listed

40. Hamptons Designer Dream Estate

1. Hamptons Designer Dream Estate

2. Hamptons Designer Dream Estate

1 of 40

Hamptons Designer Dream Estate

3 Halsey Rd, Remsenburg, NY 11960

8 Bd8 Ba

Single Family Home

$4,950,000

6,045 SF

Listed:9/16/2024$4,950,000

date	Price	variance	type
9/16/2024	$4,950,000	--	Listed

17. Ranch In Remsenburg With Great Proximity

1. Ranch In Remsenburg With Great Proximity

2. Ranch In Remsenburg With Great Proximity

1 of 17

Ranch In Remsenburg With Great Proximity

40 Nidzyn Avenue, Remsenburg, NY 11960

4 Bd3 Ba

Single Family Home

$1,375,000

2,195 SF

Reduced:6/17/2025$1,475,000(6.65%)

date	Price	variance	type
6/17/2025	$1,475,000	-6.65%	Reduced
4/7/2025	$1,580,000	-2.77%	Reduced
9/14/2024	$1,625,000	+18.18%	increased
9/13/2024	$1,375,000	--	Listed

39. Once Upon A Time

1. Once Upon A Time

2. Once Upon A Time

1 of 39

Once Upon A Time

16 Tuthill Lane, Remsenburg, NY 11960

7 Bd5 Ba

Single Family Home

$5,900,000

6,770 SF

Reduced:10/8/2024$6,999,999(17.64%)

date	Price	variance	type
10/8/2024	$6,999,999	-17.64%	Reduced
7/16/2024	$8,499,000	-13.28%	Reduced
2/9/2024	$9,800,000	+66.10%	increased
2/6/2024	$5,900,000	--	Listed

27. Captivating Country Estate

1. Captivating Country Estate

2. Captivating Country Estate

1 of 27

Captivating Country Estate

118 Country Rd, Remsenburg, NY 11960

4 Bd4 Ba

Single Family Homes

$2,575,000

3,511 SF

Reduced:9/19/2023$2,750,000(5.14%)

date	Price	variance	type
9/19/2023	$2,750,000	-5.14%	Reduced
7/25/2023	$2,899,000	+12.58%	increased
6/7/2021	$2,575,000	--	Listed

5. New Construction On Almost Two Acres

1. New Construction On Almost Two Acres

2. New Construction On Almost Two Acres

1 of 5

New Construction On Almost Two Acres

5 Remsen Lane, Remsenburg, NY 11960

5 Bd5 Ba

Single Family Homes

$4,900,000

4,500 SF

Reduced:2/1/2022$3,495,000(28.67%)

date	Price	variance	type
2/1/2022	$3,495,000	-28.67%	Reduced
12/19/2020	$4,900,000	--	Listed