Gallery
Hybrid
Map
Skip to main content
Kuper Sotheby's International Realty

Cities near Shelter Island Heights

  • Southampton Homes For Sale
  • East Hampton Homes For Sale
  • Sag Harbor Homes For Sale
  • Water Mill Homes For Sale
  • Bridgehampton Homes For Sale
  • Amagansett Homes For Sale
  • Wainscott Homes For Sale
  • Sagaponack Homes For Sale
  • Southold Homes For Sale
  • East Marion Homes For Sale
  • Cutchogue Homes For Sale
  • Mattituck Homes For Sale
  • Greenport Village Homes For Sale
  • Laurel Homes For Sale
  • Orient Homes For Sale
  • Jamesport Homes For Sale
  • Dering Harbor Homes For Sale
  • Peconic Homes For Sale
  • view more nearby cities

Shelter Island Heights Homes For Sale

  • Shelter Island Heights Land for Sale

zip near Shelter Island Heights

  • 11937 Homes For Sale
  • 11968 Homes For Sale
  • 11963 Homes For Sale
  • 11976 Homes For Sale
  • 11932 Homes For Sale
  • 11930 Homes For Sale
  • 11962 Homes For Sale
  • 11975 Homes For Sale
  • 11971 Homes For Sale
  • 11939 Homes For Sale
  • 11935 Homes For Sale
  • 11952 Homes For Sale
  • 11948 Homes For Sale
  • 11957 Homes For Sale
  • view more zips
United States New York Shelter Island Heights
Powered By: Gabriels Technology Solutions
global settings
Shelter Island Heights
(0)Status
(0)Price
(0)Bedrooms
(0)Bathrooms
(0)Type
(0)Square Feet
(0)Amenities
(0)Acres
(0)Virtual
(0)Other
(0)Keyword
Save Search

70 Homes for Sale in Shelter Island Heights, New York

123456
Google Maps Static Image
41. Shelter Island Turn-Key Waterfront With Peninsula
1. Shelter Island Turn-Key Waterfront With Peninsula
2. Shelter Island Turn-Key Waterfront With Peninsula
1 of 41
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Turn-Key Waterfront With Peninsula
5 Hagar Road (Part 3 Hagar Road), Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
3 Bd2 Ba
Single Family Home
$2,349,000
3,312 SF
Listed:4/21/2025$2,349,000
datePricevariancetype
4/21/2025$2,349,000--Listed
33. Shelter Island Designer Home With Pool Steps From Beach
1. Shelter Island Designer Home With Pool Steps From Beach
2. Shelter Island Designer Home With Pool Steps From Beach
1 of 33
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Designer Home With Pool Steps From Beach
43 Gardiners Bay Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
5 Bd5 Ba
Single Family Home
$3,700,000
5,375 SF
increased:4/12/2025$3,900,000(5.41%)
datePricevariancetype
4/12/2025$3,900,000+5.41%increased
4/10/2025$3,700,000--Listed
24. 1.8 Acre Coecles Harbor Water View Home
1. 1.8 Acre Coecles Harbor Water View Home
2. 1.8 Acre Coecles Harbor Water View Home
1 of 24
Shelter Island Heights
1.8 Acre Coecles Harbor Water View Home
75 Cobbetts Lane, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
3 Bd4 Ba
Single Family Home
$2,750,000
2,184 SF
Reduced:6/12/2025$2,995,000(7.85%)
datePricevariancetype
6/12/2025$2,995,000-7.85%Reduced
4/25/2025$3,250,000+18.18%increased
4/10/2025$2,750,000--Listed
50. Shelter Island Award-Winning Modern With Unparalleled Views
1. Shelter Island Award-Winning Modern With Unparalleled Views
2. Shelter Island Award-Winning Modern With Unparalleled Views
1 of 50
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Award-Winning Modern With Unparalleled Views
42 Prospect Avenue And 23 Serpentine Drive, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
3 Bd3 Ba
Single Family Home
$7,950,000
4,133 SF
Listed:4/9/2025$7,950,000
datePricevariancetype
4/9/2025$7,950,000--Listed
50. Shelter Island Modern Waterfront Sanctuary With Dock And Pool
1. Shelter Island Modern Waterfront Sanctuary With Dock And Pool
2. Shelter Island Modern Waterfront Sanctuary With Dock And Pool
1 of 50
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Modern Waterfront Sanctuary With Dock And Pool
11 Dickerson Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
4 Bd4 Ba
Single Family Home
$4,450,000
3,187 SF
Listed:4/9/2025$4,450,000
datePricevariancetype
4/9/2025$4,450,000--Listed
48. Waterfront Oasis On Shelter Island
1. Waterfront Oasis On Shelter Island
2. Waterfront Oasis On Shelter Island
1 of 48
Contract
Shelter Island Heights
Waterfront Oasis On Shelter Island
7 Gazon Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
3 Bd2 Ba
Single Family Home
$2,895,000
1,901 SF
Listed:4/4/2025$2,895,000
datePricevariancetype
4/4/2025$2,895,000--Listed
30. Shelter Island Shingle Style 1870 Farmhouse Near Beach
1. Shelter Island Shingle Style 1870 Farmhouse Near Beach
2. Shelter Island Shingle Style 1870 Farmhouse Near Beach
1 of 30
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Shingle Style 1870 Farmhouse Near Beach
45 West Neck Rd, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
4 Bd3 Ba
Single Family Home
$1,450,000
1,235 SF
Reduced:7/22/2025$1,665,000(10.72%)
datePricevariancetype
7/22/2025$1,665,000-10.72%Reduced
4/5/2025$1,865,000+28.62%increased
4/4/2025$1,450,000--Listed
40. Spacious Hay Beach Traditional
1. Spacious Hay Beach Traditional
2. Spacious Hay Beach Traditional
1 of 40
Shelter Island Heights
Spacious Hay Beach Traditional
27 Country Club Dr, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
3 Bd2 Ba
Single Family Home
$1,850,000
3,170 SF
increased:4/5/2025$1,990,000(7.57%)
datePricevariancetype
4/5/2025$1,990,000+7.57%increased
4/3/2025$1,850,000--Listed
44. 15 S Menantic Rd
1. 15 S Menantic Rd
2. 15 S Menantic Rd
1 of 44
Shelter Island Heights
15 S Menantic Rd
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
9 Bd4 Ba
Single Family Home
$9,955,000
Listed:3/31/2025$9,955,000
datePricevariancetype
3/31/2025$9,955,000--Listed
43. Extraordinary
1. Extraordinary
2. Extraordinary
1 of 43
Shelter Island Heights
Extraordinary
15a/15 & 13 Menantic Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
9 Bd6 Ba
Single Family Home
$9,955,000
Listed:3/29/2025$9,955,000
datePricevariancetype
3/29/2025$9,955,000--Listed
1. Shelter Island Acreage Near Resorts
Shelter Island Heights
Shelter Island Acreage Near Resorts
38 Rocky Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
Land
$995,000
Listed:3/24/2025$995,000
datePricevariancetype
3/24/2025$995,000--Listed
1. Shorewood Area Wades Beach Home
Contract
Shelter Island Heights
Shorewood Area Wades Beach Home
101 South Midway Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
2 Bd1 Ba
Single Family Home
$799,000
1,008 SF
Listed:3/21/2025$799,000
datePricevariancetype
3/21/2025$799,000--Listed

Hamptons Real Estate

Amagansett

Bridgehampton

Center Moriches

Dering Harbor Village

East Hampton North

East Hampton Town

East Hampton Village

East Moriches

East Quogue

Eastport

Flanders

Hampton Bays

Hamptons Fringe

Manorville

Montauk

Moriches

Napeague

North Haven Village

North Sea

Northampton

Northwest Woods

Noyack

Quiogue

Quogue Village

Remsenburg Speonk

Riverside

Sag Harbor

Sag Harbor Village

Sagaponack

Sagaponack Village

Shelter Island

Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island Town

Shinnecock Hills

Southampton Town

Southampton Village

Tuckahoe

Springs

Wainscott

Water Mill

Westhampton

Westhampton Beach

Westhampton Dunes

North Fork Real Estate

Aquebogue

Baiting Hollow

Calverton

Cutchogue

East Marion

Greenport Village

Greenport West

Jamesport

Laurel

Mattituck

Nassau Point

New Suffolk

Northville

Orient

Peconic

Riverhead

South Jamesport

Southold

Town of Riverhead

Town of Southold

Wading River

- Amagansett

- Bridgehampton

- Center Moriches

- Dering Harbor Village

- East Hampton North

- East Hampton Town

- East Hampton Village

- East Moriches

- East Quogue

- Eastport

- Flanders

- Hampton Bays

- Hamptons Fringe

- Manorville

- Montauk

- Moriches

- Napeague

- North Haven Village

- North Sea

- Northampton

- Northwest Woods

- Noyack

- Quiogue

- Quogue Village

- Remsenburg Speonk

- Riverside

- Sag Harbor

- Sag Harbor Village

- Sagaponack

- Sagaponack Village

- Shelter Island

- Shelter Island Heights

- Shelter Island Town

- Shinnecock Hills

- Southampton Town

- Southampton Village

- Tuckahoe

- Springs

- Wainscott

- Water Mill

- Westhampton

- Westhampton Beach

- Westhampton Dunes

- Aquebogue

- Baiting Hollow

- Calverton

- Cutchogue

- East Marion

- Greenport Village

- Greenport West

- Jamesport

- Laurel

- Mattituck

- Nassau Point

- New Suffolk

- Northville

- Orient

- Peconic

- Riverhead

- South Jamesport

- Southold

- Town of Riverhead

- Town of Southold

- Wading River

All information is from sources deemed reliable but is subject to errors, omissions, changes in price, prior sale or withdrawal without notice. No representation is made as to the accuracy of any descriptions, measurements, square footages or acreage and should not be relied upon as such. All information herein should be confirmed by the customer. All rights to all content, including but not limited to photographs, videos and other graphics, are reserved exclusively to the Broker who supplied such listing content. All advertising on this site is subject to the Federal Fair Housing Act.


Hamptons Real Estate Association is committed to fair housing laws, standard operating procedures, and reasonable accommodations.

© 2024 The Hamptons Real Estate Association - About Us  |   Terms Of Use  |   Privacy Policy  |   Fair Housing Disclosure  |   Locations  |   Sitemap

  • Sales
    • Hamptons
      • All Listings
      • Open Houses
      • Price Reduced
      • New Listings
      • Recently Sold
    • North Fork
      • All Listings
      • Open Houses
      • Price Reduced
      • New Listings
      • Recently Sold
  • Rentals
    • Hamptons
      • All Listings
      • Open Houses
      • New Listings
    • North Fork
      • All Listings
      • Open Houses
      • New Listings
  • Open Houses
    • Hamptons
      • For Sale
        • Today
        • Tomorrow
        • Next 7 Days
        • Upcoming Weekend
      • For Rent
        • Today
        • Tomorrow
        • Next 7 Days
        • Upcoming Weekend
    • North Fork
      • Today
      • Tomorrow
      • Next 7 Days
      • Upcoming Weekend
  • Sold
    • Hamptons
    • North Fork
  • BROKERAGES
  • Agents
  • About Us