Homes for Sale in Mattituck, New York

11. Charming Light-Filled Ranch In Prime Mattituck Location

1. Charming Light-Filled Ranch In Prime Mattituck Location

2. Charming Light-Filled Ranch In Prime Mattituck Location

1 of 11

Charming Light-Filled Ranch In Prime Mattituck Location

10890 Old Sound Avenue, Mattituck, NY 11952

3 Bd3 Ba

Single Family Home

$599,999

1,200 SF

Listed:7/21/2025$599,999

date	Price	variance	type
7/21/2025	$599,999	--	Listed

41. 4235 Camp Mineola Road, Mattituck, Ny

1. 4235 Camp Mineola Road, Mattituck, Ny

2. 4235 Camp Mineola Road, Mattituck, Ny

1 of 41

Reduced

4235 Camp Mineola Road, Mattituck, Ny

Mattituck, NY 11952

4 Bd2 Ba

Single Family Home

$1,750,000

2,072 SF

increased:7/14/2025$1,875,000(7.14%)

date	Price	variance	type
7/14/2025	$1,875,000	+7.14%	increased
7/12/2025	$1,750,000	--	Listed

12. 1500 Marys Road

1. 1500 Marys Road

2. 1500 Marys Road

1 of 12

Contract

1500 Marys Road

Mattituck, NY 11952

5 Bd2 Ba

Single Family Home

$1,600,000

2,140 SF

Reduced:5/2/2025$1,500,000(6.25%)

date	Price	variance	type
5/2/2025	$1,500,000	-6.25%	Reduced
4/21/2025	$1,600,000	--	Listed

37. Sexy Sound Front Stunner

1. Sexy Sound Front Stunner

2. Sexy Sound Front Stunner

1 of 37

Sexy Sound Front Stunner

470 Lloyds Lane, Mattituck, NY 11952

4 Bd5 Ba

Single Family Home

$5,950,000

4,929 SF

increased:6/12/2025$6,250,000(5.04%)

date	Price	variance	type
6/12/2025	$6,250,000	+5.04%	increased
4/18/2025	$5,950,000	--	Listed

25. Prime Hamlet Business Property With Retail & Residential Income

1. Prime Hamlet Business Property With Retail & Residential Income

2. Prime Hamlet Business Property With Retail & Residential Income

1 of 25

Prime Hamlet Business Property With Retail & Residential Income

13100 Main Road, Mattituck, NY 11952

3 Bd3 Ba

Single Family Home

$1,795,000

3,610 SF

increased:6/6/2025$1,950,000(8.64%)

date	Price	variance	type
6/6/2025	$1,950,000	+8.64%	increased
3/19/2025	$1,795,000	--	Listed

36. Soundfront Oasis

1. Soundfront Oasis

2. Soundfront Oasis

1 of 36

Soundfront Oasis

4105 Soundview Avenue, Mattituck, NY 11952

3 Bd3 Ba

Single Family Home

$5,750,000

3,557 SF

Listed:2/27/2025$5,750,000

date	Price	variance	type
2/27/2025	$5,750,000	--	Listed

25. 13100 Main Road

1. 13100 Main Road

2. 13100 Main Road

1 of 25

13100 Main Road

Mattituck, NY 11952

3 Ba

Commercial

$1,795,000

3,610 SF

increased:6/6/2025$1,950,000(8.64%)

date	Price	variance	type
6/6/2025	$1,950,000	+8.64%	increased
2/25/2025	$1,795,000	--	Listed

12. 1.8 Acres In Prime Location

1. 1.8 Acres In Prime Location

2. 1.8 Acres In Prime Location

1 of 12

Contract

1.8 Acres In Prime Location

1500 Marys Road, Mattituck, NY 11952

Land

$399,000

Reduced:2/3/2025$629,000(10.01%)

date	Price	variance	type
2/3/2025	$629,000	-10.01%	Reduced
1/17/2025	$699,000	+75.19%	increased
1/7/2025	$399,000	--	Listed

30. 2100 Park Avenue

1. 2100 Park Avenue

2. 2100 Park Avenue

1 of 30

2100 Park Avenue

Mattituck, NY 11952

5 Bd3 Ba

Single Family Home

$5,900,000

4,119 SF

Reduced:12/14/2024$6,250,000(9.35%)

date	Price	variance	type
12/14/2024	$6,250,000	-9.35%	Reduced
7/23/2024	$6,895,000	+16.86%	increased
6/9/2024	$5,900,000	--	Listed

35. Looking For A Waterfront Getaway?

1. Looking For A Waterfront Getaway?

2. Looking For A Waterfront Getaway?

1 of 35

Contract

Looking For A Waterfront Getaway?

2500 Ole Jule Ln, Mattituck, NY 11952

4 Bd2 Ba

Single Family Home

$949,000

2,200 SF

Listed:3/22/2024$949,000

date	Price	variance	type
3/22/2024	$949,000	--	Listed